Insights / Efficiency, Scalability and Profitability
The True Cost of Manual Medical Record Review for Mid-Sized Law Firms
By Breen LNC.
Short answer: We did not find a published benchmark for what manual record review costs a law firm, and any single figure would be a guess. You can work out your own: time a few real files, apply your loaded labor rate, then add the costs that never appear on a timesheet.
Start with the wage data
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports median pay for paralegals and legal assistants of $62,890 a year, or $30.24 an hour, as of May 2025. Registered nurses had a median of $97,550, or $46.90 an hour. Your own figures may run higher or lower, and these medians leave out benefits, overhead and a legal nurse consultant’s market rate. BLS does not publish a separate figure for legal nurse consultants on these pages.
A worksheet you can fill in
- Choose three closed cases of different sizes.
- Record the total pages in each and the hours your team spent reading and summarizing them.
- Divide to get pages per hour for your team, not someone else’s.
- Multiply hours by your loaded hourly rate, including benefits and overhead.
- Add attorney time spent re-reading to confirm what the summary says.
That gives a real cost per case, grounded in your own work.
The costs a timesheet misses
Repetition. Clinical notes repeat themselves a lot, so your staff may read many of the same words twice. A study of 104 million notes at one health system found 50.1% of the words were exact duplicates of earlier text about the same patient. Your files will differ, but it’s worth asking how much paid reading goes to pages already read.
Cases you pass on. If records capacity limits how many complex cases you accept, the cost is the fee you never earned. Only you can estimate that one.
Delay. Time in a queue is time before a demand goes out. We did not find a source that puts a dollar value on this, so we won’t offer one.
Expertise. A careful paralegal can build a clean timeline. Clinical flags need clinical training, so a low hourly rate can hide what the review didn’t catch, and you’d only find that out later.
Compare the same thing on each side
When you price an alternative, compare equal outputs. A cheap automated summary that your attorneys must then re-verify may not cost less overall. Ask what you actually receive, who checked it and how much of your team’s time it still needs. Then put those numbers next to your worksheet.
Whichever way it comes out, the answer should come from your own numbers.
Frequently asked questions
How much does medical record review cost a law firm?
We did not find a reliable published benchmark. Time a few closed cases, apply your loaded labor rate, and add attorney re-reading time to get your own figure.
What do paralegals and registered nurses earn?
BLS reports May 2025 median pay of $62,890 for paralegals and legal assistants and $97,550 for registered nurses. These are national medians for the whole occupation.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Paralegals and Legal Assistants
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, Registered Nurses
- Steinkamp et al., Prevalence and Sources of Duplicate Information in the Electronic Medical Record, JAMA Network Open (2022)
General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.