Insights / Complex Injuries and Clinical Expertise
Traumatic Brain Injuries With Normal Imaging: What Attorneys Need to Know
By Breen LNC.
Short answer: A normal head CT does not by itself rule out a mild traumatic brain injury. One small study reported abnormal early MRI in 27% of patients with normal CTs, and larger studies report functional problems months later in many CT-negative patients. These are group findings, so they do not establish causation in any one case.
What a normal scan does and doesn’t say
The CDC describes mild TBI symptoms as physical, cognitive, emotional and sleep-related, and notes that some appear right away while others “may not appear for hours or days after the injury.” It also says most people feel better within a couple of weeks. Both statements matter, and a fair reading of a case keeps them together.
A CT looks for certain acute findings, such as bleeding. In a TRACK-TBI study of 135 mild TBI patients, 27% of those with a normal admission head CT had an abnormal brain MRI about 12 days later. It was a small study at three level I trauma centers, and it looked at predicting outcomes.
Persistent problems in CT-negative patients
Two larger TRACK-TBI papers followed patients for longer.
- Madhok and colleagues followed patients with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 15 and no acute injury on CT. Among those followed up, 73% had incomplete recovery at two weeks and 56% at six months. Incomplete recovery here means a score below 8 on a broad functional scale.
- Nelson and colleagues found functional limitations at 12 months in 53% of mild TBI patients and 38% of orthopedic trauma controls. CT-negative patients still had a higher risk than controls (relative risk 1.28). The authors wrote that “this injury is not always benign.”
Note the limits. These patients came to level I trauma centers and received a head CT, so they may not represent milder cases seen elsewhere. Follow-up was incomplete, and the outcome scale doesn’t identify a specific symptom. The orthopedic controls had limitations too, which is why the comparison matters.
Words in the chart
The American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine’s 2023 criteria paper reports that 93.8% of its panel agreed “concussion” may be used interchangeably with “mild TBI” when neuroimaging is normal or not clinically indicated. If one provider writes concussion and another writes mild TBI, they may be describing the same thing.
What to look for in the record
- What was documented at the scene and at triage, including any loss of consciousness or confusion
- Follow-up: the Madhok authors suggest a two-week visit to identify who needs rehabilitation
- First mention of each symptom, with date
- Pre-injury baseline, including prior concussions, headaches, or mental health treatment
- Neuropsychological or MRI testing, if ordered, and when
- Function at work and at home, in the provider’s own words
Causation and prognosis belong with your treating providers and experts. A Breen nurse can lay out what the chart shows and where the gaps are, so you know what to ask them.
Frequently asked questions
Can you have a brain injury with a normal CT scan?
Research shows it can happen. One study found about a quarter of mild TBI patients with a normal CT had an abnormal MRI about 12 days later. Diagnosis in any individual case is for treating providers.
How long do mild TBI symptoms last?
The CDC says most people feel better within a couple of weeks. Research on patients seen at trauma centers reports that some still have functional limits months later, and those findings may not apply to all patients.
Sources
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Symptoms of Mild TBI and Concussion
- Yuh et al., Magnetic resonance imaging improves 3-month outcome prediction in mild traumatic brain injury, Annals of Neurology (2013)
- Madhok et al., Outcomes in Patients With Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Without Acute Intracranial Traumatic Injury, JAMA Network Open (2022)
- Nelson et al., Recovery After Mild Traumatic Brain Injury in Patients Presenting to US Level I Trauma Centers, JAMA Neurology (2019)
- Silverberg et al., The American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine Diagnostic Criteria for Mild Traumatic Brain Injury, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation (2023)
General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.