Insights / AI in Personal Injury Litigation

The Rise of AI in Personal Injury Litigation: What Every Plaintiff Attorney Should Know

By Breen LNC.

Short answer: AI use in law is growing, and the best-known sanctions order makes one thing plain: the tool is allowed, but the attorney answers for what gets filed. Plaintiff attorneys should know the adoption numbers, that case and the bar guidance before they rely on AI output in an injury case.

How common is it?

Surveys differ because they measure different things. Thomson Reuters reported in 2025 that 28% of law firm respondents were using generative AI, in a survey of more than 1,700 professionals across several fields. The ABA’s 2024 survey, as reported by the ABA Journal, put the figure at 30% of responding lawyers, ranging from 18% of solo attorneys to 46% at firms of 100 or more. Thomson Reuters sells legal AI products, and neither figure isolates personal injury practice. They do show that AI has moved past early experiments.

The case every attorney should read

The best-known warning began as a personal injury claim. In Mata v. Avianca, a passenger alleged that a metal serving cart struck his knee on a flight. His lawyers filed opposition papers citing opinions that did not exist, created by ChatGPT, and kept standing by them after the court questioned them. The court imposed a $5,000 penalty and required letters to the plaintiff and to each judge falsely named as an author.

Judge Castel was careful about what he was punishing. He wrote that there was “nothing inherently improper about using a reliable artificial intelligence tool for assistance.” The problem was the failure of the attorney’s gatekeeping role.

What bar guidance says

Washington’s 2025 advisory opinion says “the duties of competence and confidentiality ultimately remain the lawyer’s.” It warns that some consumer AI products carry no contractual assurance of confidentiality. Arizona’s committee guidance quotes ABA Formal Opinion 512 for the point that relying on AI output without an appropriate degree of independent verification or review could violate the duty of competence. These are advisory documents from two jurisdictions, so check the rules in yours.

What to do with this

Medical records raise the stakes on both duties, because the facts are clinical and the information is sensitive. Pick tools you have vetted, know who checks the output, and make sure that person is qualified to catch a clinical mistake. Breen’s answer is a nurse on every entry, with a page cite you can check yourself.

Frequently asked questions

Is it improper for a lawyer to use AI?

Not by itself. The Mata v. Avianca order said there is nothing inherently improper about using a reliable AI tool for assistance, while placing a gatekeeping role on attorneys for what they file.

Was Mata v. Avianca a personal injury case?

Yes. The underlying claim alleged that a metal serving cart struck the plaintiff’s left knee on a flight. The sanctions concerned fake case citations, not medical records.

Sources

General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.