Insights / Medical Evidence, Causation and Case Value

Preexisting Conditions, Degenerative Findings, and Causation: What AI Might Miss

By Breen LNC.

Short answer: Degenerative findings are common even in people without pain, so their presence alone says little about what caused a symptom. A useful way to look at causation is the before and after: function, complaints and treatment over time. AI can list findings and still miss that story, so a clinician should build it from the record.

Common findings are not automatically old injuries

A systematic review in the American Journal of Neuroradiology, covering 3,110 people without symptoms, reported disc degeneration in 37% of 20-year-olds and 96% of 80-year-olds. Disc bulges ranged from 30% to 84% across those same ages. The authors concluded many of these findings are likely part of normal aging and should be read alongside the clinical picture.

That cuts in two directions. The defense can’t assume that a bulge on an MRI explains the client’s pain. You can’t assume the collision caused it. The study doesn’t resolve any one person’s case. It explains why imaging alone rarely answers the question.

The whiplash literature adds to this. A 2007 review says the most common radiographic findings in whiplash are preexisting degenerative disease or slight loss of cervical lordosis, and that the injury itself most often isn’t identified on imaging in the acute phase.

The law may help, and it varies

The eggshell skull rule, as Cornell’s legal dictionary describes it, holds a defendant liable for the full extent of a plaintiff’s unusual reaction to a wrongful act, as long as the act caused the injury. How aggravation and apportionment work in your state is a legal question for you. Our sources didn’t address it.

What software can flatten

A summary might report “degenerative changes at L4-5” and “low back pain” as two tidy entries. The questions that matter sit between those lines:

  • Did the person have complaints in that area before? How often, and how bad?
  • Were they working full duty, without restrictions?
  • Was there any treatment in the years before the event?
  • What changed afterward, and when did the chart first show it?
  • Did a treating provider connect the two, and on what basis?

Comparing years of records and reasoning about change over time takes clinical sense. In JAMA Internal Medicine, AI narratives were less comprehensive than physician ones. That isn’t a causation study, but it’s a reason to check that prior history hasn’t been dropped or smoothed over.

Build the before and after

Ask your nurse for a side-by-side view of the period before the event and the period after: complaints, function, treatment and medications, each with a page cite. Prior records can help when they show someone who was doing fine.

Causation itself is for you and your experts to establish. Breen’s nurses organize the clinical facts so that those conversations start from the record.

Frequently asked questions

Are degenerative findings on an MRI always from an old injury?

They are common in people with no symptoms. One systematic review found disc degeneration in 37% of asymptomatic 20-year-olds and 96% of 80-year-olds, and advised reading findings with the clinical picture.

What is the eggshell skull rule?

A common law doctrine that a defendant takes the victim as found and is liable for the full extent of unusual reactions to a wrongful act, as long as the act caused the injury. Application varies by jurisdiction.

Sources

General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.