Insights / Medical Evidence, Causation and Case Value
The Medical Evidence That May Be Missing From Your Demand Package
By Breen LNC.
Short answer: Before sending a demand, check for records you never received, itemized bills that match the treatment, lien amounts, proof of how the injury changed daily life, future care support and a clear causation explanation. Gaps like these are easier to fix before the demand goes out.
One caveat first. We did not find an authoritative source on how adjusters weigh a demand, so this is a checklist of what a thorough file contains, not a formula for a higher number.
Records you think you have
HIPAA’s designated record set includes medical and billing records and records used to make decisions about an individual. Compare what arrived against that scope and your treatment timeline. Common places to check are a provider seen once, an outside imaging report, therapy notes after discharge and any new treatment since your first request. Note that the patient access right excludes psychotherapy notes and information compiled in reasonable anticipation of a legal proceeding, so a missing item may need another route.
Bills that tie to treatment
Cornell’s legal dictionary describes special damages as ascertainable losses like medical expenses. Each charge should tie to a visit you can point to in the record. Look for duplicate charges, and for treatment that appears in the notes but not in the bills, or the reverse. It is better to find a mismatch yourself than to hear about it from the other side.
Liens and conditional payments
If Medicare paid, it may expect repayment. CMS defines a conditional payment as a payment Medicare makes for services another payer may be responsible for, to be repaid when a settlement is reached. CMS says the total is interim while the claim is pending, so confirm the current figure before you rely on it. Private plans and hospital liens have their own rules.
How life changed
Pain and limitation may be thinly documented in the chart itself. Look for function: what the person can’t lift, how far they can walk, what work restrictions a provider actually wrote. Then consider whether your file has their own account, or that of family or coworkers, along with the medical records.
What the future holds
A permanent impairment or expected surgery needs support from a treating provider or an expert. A summary that stops at the last visit can leave this unsaid.
Why this injury, from this event
If the chart shows prior complaints or degenerative findings, address them directly with clinical support. Leaving them unmentioned can invite the other side to raise them first.
Have someone check the whole package
Ask a nurse to read the medical portion against the record before it goes out. Each medical statement should trace to a page. Breen’s demand work draws from the nurse-checked record, and the attorney adds liability and the number.
Frequently asked questions
What medical records should be in a personal injury demand package?
A complete set for each provider, itemized bills that tie to treatment, lien information, documentation of function, support for future care and clinical support for causation. Requirements vary by case and jurisdiction.
Do Medicare conditional payments affect a settlement?
They can. CMS describes them as payments to be repaid when a settlement is reached, and says the amount is interim while the claim is pending. Confirm the current figure with CMS and your counsel.
Sources
- 45 CFR 164.501, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- 45 CFR 164.524, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Special damages, Wex, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Medicare’s Recovery Process
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Conditional Payment Information
General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.