Insights / AI Risk Management and Quality Assurance
AI in Litigation: Why Source Citations and Medical Record Traceability Matter
By Breen LNC.
Short answer: A citation lets someone outside the software check the claim. In AI-assisted work, that is the main safeguard. Sanctions cases show what happens when no one checks. Real traceability means each medical fact links to the exact page and line, and someone has actually opened it.
What happens without it
The citation failures that made headlines involved case law. In Mata v. Avianca, lawyers filed opinions that didn’t exist. When doubt arose, one lawyer asked ChatGPT “Is Varghese a real case,” and it assured him it was. In Kohls v. Ellison, described in Washington’s advisory opinion, an expert declaration cited non-existent academic articles generated by an AI tool, and the court struck the declaration.
In both, opening the source would have exposed the problem. Asking the system that made the error did not.
Why medical records raise the stakes
A medical fact in your file may end up in a demand, an expert’s report or a deposition question. If someone asks where it came from, “the summary says so” won’t help. The Michigan Bar Journal’s guidance recommends recording discrete facts and citing their source, advice that applies to any chronology and matters even more when software writes the first draft.
Traceability helps with honest differences too. Records contradict themselves. If you can jump to the page, you can see which note said what, who wrote it and when.
A cite isn’t the same as verification
A citation can be wrong in quieter ways:
- It may point to a real page that doesn’t say what the entry claims.
- The page may say it, but as a copied line from a much earlier visit.
- The quote may be accurate but leave out a sentence that changes the meaning.
AHIMA’s record integrity brief adds another layer: audit trails can show what was amended, by whom and when. The page itself can have a history worth asking about.
So a good system checks whether the quoted words actually appear on the cited page, and then has a person decide whether they mean what the entry says.
What to require from any tool or vendor
- Every medical fact links to a specific page, with a stable number such as a Bates number.
- The exact supporting line is shown, not just a page range.
- The software confirms that the quote matches the page text.
- A clinician reviews entry and source side by side.
- Changes are logged with a name and a date.
Traceability protects your own credibility
It makes your work easy to check, including by you at 9 p.m. the night before a mediation. At Breen, every entry carries its page cite and the exact line it rests on, and the software checks each quote against the page text before a nurse decides it.
Frequently asked questions
Why do source citations matter in AI legal work?
They let a person check the claim outside the software. In Mata v. Avianca, opening the cited sources would have revealed the fake opinions. Asking ChatGPT did not.
Is a page citation enough to trust an AI entry?
Not by itself. The page may not say what the entry claims or may be a copied line. A clinician should read the entry and the source together.
Sources
- Mata v. Avianca, Inc., No. 22-cv-1461, Opinion and Order on Sanctions (S.D.N.Y. June 22, 2023)
- Washington State Bar Association, Advisory Opinion 2025-05, Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Tools in Law Practice (2025)
- Greg Krehel, Chronology Best Practices, Michigan Bar Journal
- AHIMA, Integrity of the Healthcare Record: Best Practices for EHR Documentation (2013 update)
General information for legal professionals. This is not legal or medical advice.